Consignment & Thrift Shops go Results Found: 4 Button group with nested dropdown Unitarian Universalist Meeting House - Bear-ly Used Thrift Shop 819 Main Street Chatham MA 02633 (508) 945-2075 Uncommon Thrift at St. Christopher's 637C Main Street (behind the Orpheum Theater) Chatham MA 02633 (508) 945-2211 South Chatham Community Church Benefit Shop PO Box 52 2555 Main Street S Chatham MA 02659 (508) 432-3719 First United Methodist Church of Chatham - Thrift Shop 16 Cross Street Chatham MA 02633 (508) 945-0474